20 Best Restaurants in Key West
1. SEASIDE CAFE AT THE MANSION
Seaside Cafe at the Mansion is a restaurant with outdoor seating that serves delicious seafood, incredible pizza, and tasty sandwiches.
Located in The Southernmost House Hotel, this eatery is open every day starts from 11.30 AM until 8.00 PM, and you can also enjoy the great view of the ocean from Seaside Cafe at the Mansion.
There are options of food available that you can try here such as Coconut Shrimp, Parmesan Truffle Fries, Island Ahi Salad, Wood-Fired Caprese, Traditional Pizza, Hot Honey Salami Pizza, Veggie Pizza, Piña Colada Key Lime Pie, and Classic Key Lime Pie.
Seaside Cafe at the Mansion
2. THE LOBSTER SHACK KEY WEST
The Lobster Shack Key West is one of the best seafood restaurants in Key West Florida. The Lobster Shack Key West is located at 507 South Street, starts open from 11.00 AM until 5.00 PM on Tuesday to Sunday, and it offers quick service, excellent staff, and high-quality lobster.
There are some lobster cuisines available which include, Key West Lobster Roll with fresh key lime juice, Traditional New England Roll with a touch of mayo, Lobster "BLT" Roll with Applewood Smoked Bacon, Diablo Lobster Roll, The Lobster Grilled Cheese, Shrimp Roll, The Best Lobster Bisque, Coconut Shrimp, and Kermit's Key Lime Pie.
The Lobster Shack Key West
3. OFF THE HOOK GRILL
Off The Hook Grill is a cozy American bistro which has an appetizers menu, salad menu, sandwich menu, pizza menu, dessert menu, and dinner menu. Visit this restaurant when they are open from around 4.00 PM until 9.00 PM almost every day except Wednesday.
For the appetizers and salad menu, you can have Fried Green Tomatoes, Tuna Poke, Lightly Fried Calamari Steak, Seafood Deviled Eggs, Lobster & Shrimp Salad, and Seafood Deviled Eggs. Then, you can have Filet Mignon Beef Tips, Snapper Moqueca, Spicy Shrimp, Scallops over Pork Belly, Local Blackfin Tuna Poke Bowl, Lobster Mac, and Cheese, and Tikka Masala Curry Chicken Thighs.
Off the Hook Grill Key West
4. KEY PLAZA CREPERIE
Key Plaza Creperie is a restaurant serves sweet and savory crepes, salads, sandwiches, and a breakfast menu. Situated in Key Plaza, Key Plaza Creperie is open daily from 7.00 AM until 5.00 PM and you can visit this eatery as long as it's open with family or friends.
Then, you can have some food options available which include, Tuna Salad, Greek Chicken, Smoked Salmon, Spicy Tuna Salad, Caprese, Tuna Melt, Cheese Omelette, Meat Lovers Omelette, NY Strip Steak & Eggs, and Breakfast Wrap. For the crepes sweet and savory, there are Nutella, Raspberry Jam, Key Lime Creamy Filled, Organic Buckwheat, Galette Greek Salad, Goat Cheese, Alaskan, and KPC.
Key Plaza Creperie
5. SANTIAGO'S BODEGA | KEY WEST
Santiago's Bodega | Key West offers good things such as a cozy atmosphere, incredible service, and very good food. This eatery is located at 207 Petronia Street, it's also open every day from 11.00 AM until 10.00 PM.
For the food options, you can have Spicy Shrimp Bisque, French Onion, Spinach, Beef Carpaccio, Smoked Salmon Carpaccio, Yellowfin Tuna Ceviche, Mozzarella Burrata, Petite-rack Lamb, Saganaki, Roman Meatballs, Brussels Sprouts, Beef Tenderloin, Beef Short Ribs, and Croquettas.
Santiago's Bodega | Key West
6. TAVERN N' TOWN
Tavern N' Town is located in Key West Marriot Beachside Hotel, open daily from 8.00 AM until 11.30 AM and open again 5.00 until 10.00 PM, then it serves tapas and Key West-inspired entrees.
There are several foods on the tapas menu which include, Crispy Castelvetrano Olives, Ribeye Stream Buns, Tuna Poke, Naked Chicken Wings, Fresh Calamari, and Shrimp Fritters. Then, you can have Prime Rib, Local Catch, Ora King Salmon, Colorado Lamb, Crispy Chicken, and Chef's Seasonal Vegetarian Dish on the Entrees menu.
Tavern N' Town
7. AZUR RESTAURANT
Azur Restaurant is the first Mediterranean eatery on this list and serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner place which is very recommended to visit in Key West, Florida.
This eatery is located at 425 Grinnell Street and open every day from 9.00 AM until 3.00 PM and open again from 5.30 PM until 10.00 PM. The menu at Azur Restaurant will never let the guests down, there are Key West Pink Shrimp, Beef Carpaccio, Steamed Mussels, Braised Beef Rib, Seafood Risotto, Branzino, Yellowtail Snapper, Rack of Lamb, Pan-Roasted Chicken, Confit Duck Leg, and Angus Rib Eye Steak.
Azur Restaurant
8. DUETTO PIZZA AND GELATO
If you love pizza and looking for the best pizza restaurant in Key West, Duetto Pizza and Gelato has to be on your list. Located at 540 Greene Street #1, Duetto Pizza and Gelato is open daily from 11.00 AM until 10.00 PM and you can visit this Italian eatery as long as you want.
Then, there are several food options available such as Caesar Salad, Greek Salad, Meatballs, Plain Cheese Pie, Pepperoni, La Margherita Classica, Caprese, Con Carne, Parmigiana, Spicy Salame, Philly Cheese Steak, Spinach Ricotta, Focaccia Sandwich, Breadsticks, and Garlic Cheese Bread.
Duetto Pizza and Gelato
9. MOONDOG CAFE
Moondog Cafe is the perfect destination to spend your breakfast, lunch, and dinner that serves a lot of delicious food. You can visit this eatery when they are open start from 7.30 AM until 9.30 PM every day and it's located at 823 Whitehead Street.
For the breakfast menu, there are Feel Good Bowl, Quiche Lorraine, Shakshuka, Smoked Salmon Benedict, Blackened Shrimp Benedict, Chorizo & Cheese, Caprese Croissant Benedict, Buttermilk Pancakes, Brioche French Toast, Ahi Tuna Poke, Roasted Garlic-Honey Bruschetta, Spinach Gyoza Dumplings, and Sweet Potato Fries.
Moondog Cafe
10. GOLDMAN'S DELI
Goldman's Deli is a traditional bagel and Jewish deli spot which offers soups and pastrami sandwiches.
This eatery is located in Overseas Market, open daily from 6.45 AM until 3.30 PM and you can visit it every day as long as it's open. You'll be offered variants of eats available such as Tuna Melt, Patty Melt, Roast Beef Panini, The Reuben, Yellow Submarine Cheese Burger, Hot Corned Beef, Chopped Liver, Chicken Salad, Black Forest Ham, Italian Wrap, Tuna Nicoise, and Garden Salad.
Goldman's Deli
11. EL SIBONEY RESTAURANT
El Siboney Restaurant is a Cuban restaurant that you have to go to while coming to Key West, Florida. You'll be offered traditional Cuban home cooking, a family-friendly setting, friendly staff, great service, and very tasty food.
Start open from 11.00 AM, El Siboney Restaurant offers you guys Roast Pork, Pork Tenderloin, Siboney Steak, Palomilla Steak, Teriyaki Steak, Liver Steak, Grilled Mahi, Grilled Snapper, Teriyaki Chicken, BBQ Chicken, Chicken Soup Bowl, Cheese Empanada, Croqueta, Chessy Yuca Bites, Picadillo Sandwich, Key Lime Pie, and many more.
El Siboney Restaurant
12. EATON STREET SEAFOOD MARKET & RESTAURANT
Another seafood eatery that you should visit in Key West, it's Eaton Street Seafood Market & Restaurant. Find this seafood restaurant at 801 Eaton Street and open daily from 11.00 AM until 9.00 PM.
This restaurant has two different menus available, lunch and dinner menu. There are Lobster Roll, Crab Cake Sandwich, Shrimp Salad, Fried Fish, Grilled Lobster Tail, Tuna Salad Sandwich, Stone Crab Market Price, Buffalo Shrimp, Conch Ceviche, Chicken Tenders, New England Clam Chowder, Conch Fritters, and Conch Chowder.
Eaton Street Seafood Market & Restaurant
13. CAFE MARQUESA KEY WEST
Cafe Marquesa Key West is located in Marquesa Hotel, open every day from 5.30 PM until 10.00 PM, and offers all the guests great service, a cozy atmosphere, and tasty dishes.
Cafe Marquesa Key West has starters and entrees menu which contain Spiny Lobster and Fried Green Tomatoes, Shrimp and Grits, Seared Hudson Valley Foie Gras, She Crab Soup, Baby Gem Lettuce, Beef Carpaccio, Oysters Rockefeller, Crispy Hogfish, Beef Tenderloin, Pan-Seared Sea Scallops, Crispy Pork Osso Bucco, Roasted Maple Leaf Farms Duck Breast, and Grilled Scottish Salmon.
Cafe Marquesa Key West
14. FRITA'S CUBAN BURGERS
Frita's Cuban Burgers is one of the best Cuban restaurants that you have to visit in Key West, Florida. This restaurant gives all the guests outdoor seating, good service, and delicious food.
Then, you'll be pampered with variants of eats which include, Traditional Frita Burger, Frita Chicken Burger, Gaucho Burger, Yellowtail Fish Frita, Cuban Chicken Tacos, Local Fish Taco, Perro Cuban Hot dog, Traditional Cubanito Sandwich, Shrimp Tacos, and Bar Tortilla Chips and Dips.
Frita's Cuban Burgers
15. FRENCHIE'S CAFE
Frenchie's Cafe serves French-style fare and a perfect place to visit for breakfast and lunch. Located at 529 United Street, Frenchie's Cafe starts open from 7.00 AM until 3.00 PM on Thursday to Tuesday and offers great service with fantastic food.
There is some delicious food available which includes, Croque-Madame Breakfast Sandwich, Croque-Salmon Breakfast Sandwich, Ham Sandwich, Smoked Salmon Sandwich, French Hot Dog Hot, Ham-Swiss Cheese Panini, Salmon-Brie Panini, Chocolate Croissant, French Baguette, Cinnamon Roll, and still more to go.
Frenchie's Cafe
16. MO'S RESTAURANT
Mo's Restaurant is a chill eatery with classic creole and island comfort eats, located at 1116 White Street, and starts open from 12.00 PM until 10.00 PM. This eatery has two different types of menu available, appetizers and entrees menu.
The appetizer menu includes some delicious food such as Teriyaki Chicken Wings, Baked Cheddar, Fry Plantain, Escargot, and Crab Cakes. Then, for the entrees menu, you can have Chicken Casserole, Creole Shrimp Pasta and Veggies, Seafood Ragu, Creole Shrimp with Rice and Mixed Vegetables, Caribbean Roasted Chicken, Barbecue Chicken, Ribeye Steak, and New York Strip.
Mo's Restaurant
17. LAGERHEADS BEACH BAR
If you are looking for an amazing place to enjoy the incredible view of the sunset and overlooking the ocean, Lagerheads Beach Bar might the best destination for you. Located in Pier House Resort and Spa, Lagerheads Beach Bar starts open from 10.00 AM until 5.30 PM every day and offers top-quality food.
Then, you'll be offered a lot of tasty dishes available, there are Fish Tacos, Fish Sandwich, Crab Cake Sandwich, Caribbean Crab Cakes, Conch Ceviche, Blackened Chicken Sandwich with Mango Salsa and Avocado, Island Quesadillas, Fresh Garden Salad, Smoked Fish Dip, Tuna Salad Wrap, Hummus Platter, and Hummus Veggie Wrap.
Lagerheads Beach Bar & Watersports
18. OLD TOWN MEXICAN CAFE
Old Town Mexican Cafe is one of the best Mexican restaurants that you can visit while coming to Key West, Florida.
This eatery is located at 609 Duva Street, open daily from 11.30 AM until 10.30 PM, and offers delicious and flavorful food. Then, for the food selections, you can have Grilled Shrimp, Guacamole, Crab Cakes, Tortilla Soup Classico, Mexican Lasagna, Carne Asada, Santa Fe Carne Adovoda, Baja Tacos, Marinated Grilled Salmon Tacos, Seafood Veracruz, and Garden Burrito.
Old Town Mexican Cafe
19. BISTRO 245
Bistro 245 is an American restaurant offers upscale American menu, good service, a cozy atmosphere and you can enjoy the beautiful ocean view from this eatery.
Besides it, the food in this restaurant will never let you down, there are Onion Soup, Lobster Quesadilla, Maine Lobster Mac & Cheese, Grilled Shrimp & Quinoa, Grilled Half Pound Burger, Smoked Turkey Club, Grouper Sandwich, Pacific Coast Chicken, Monte Cristo, Ahi Tuna Tacos, Key Lime Pie, Mississippi Mud Pie, and Espresso Creme Brulee.
Bistro 245
20. CAROLINE'S CAFE
Caroline's Cafe is the last eatery on these best 20 restaurants list in Key West, Florida. It's located at 310 Duval Street, open from 11.00 AM until 11.30 PM, and offers great food, incredible service, awesome staff, and reasonable prices for the guests.
For the food options, there are Conch Fritters, Chicken Wings, Sesame Ahi Tuna, Quesadilla, Bamboozled Salad, Cheese Steak, Dolphin Sandwich, Cajun Blackened Chicken Sandwich, Caribbean Steak, Spicy Cajun Jambalaya, Island Style Roast Pork Bowl, and Homemade Key Lime Pie.
Caroline's Cafe
